Craftsmart clay gets a lot of hate here (rightfully so), but it's my favorite. Here are some game pieces I've created with it! June 2019 vs January 2021 - Settlers of Catan
Natural Air-Dry Clay by Craft Smart - Non-Toxic Clay for Hand Modeling, Sculpting, Pottery - Terracotta, 10lbs, Bulk 4 Pack - Walmart.com
Modeling Clay Set by Craft Smart - 72 Pieces - MAKE OFFER! | eBay
Craftsmart clay gets a lot of hate here (rightfully so), but it's my favorite. Here are some game pieces I've created with it! June 2019 vs January 2021 - Settlers of Catan